What COVID-19 means for undocumented workers

As several other posts on this blog have mentioned, the COVID-19 pandemic could have drastic consequences for the food supply chain given social distancing restrictions? But what about the workers this leaves in the lurch?

There are more than 2.4 million farmworkers across the United States and most of them are undocumented. Considered essential workers, but not given the same protections as others and without health insurance, agricultural laborers are at a high risk of catching the virus and have been having trouble obtaining personal protective equipment. 

A farmworker in Immokalee, Florida, waits aboard a crowded field bus for the pre-dawn drive to work on a local farm. Photo by Scott Robertson.

With over half a dozen cases in America’s “tomato capital,” and more on farms across the country, this will significantly limit some region’s ability to cultivate crops as workers will have a harder time recovering without health insurance and will likely be ostracized from work if they catch it.

It’s yet another example of how America, both politically and socially, is once again kicking migrants to the curb and turning a blind eye to foreseeable problems in favor of hoping things work out by continuing to exploit vulnerable populations. 

While dollars from the stimulus package are going to many affected workers, undocumented laborers are getting none of it and who knows how much will be spent on occupational safety, according to the Food & Environment Reporting Network.

Obviously the world food system is just that: a system. And when one step in that system is forced to sputter, things can go off the rails. So they’ll probably regret this decision of inaction when the supply of fruits and vegetables from these farms suddenly aren’t as plentiful as the fields are under-staffed and overworked. 

It’s good to see activists working on behalf of these silenced workers because otherwise this important story would once again not be told.

Virus is changing how urban farms operate, and even what they grow

Urban farms such as the Red Hook Farms in Brooklyn, New York, have been organized in a way where it is cramped in order for its many farmers to be able to produce as much as possible. However, because of the coronavirus outbreak, many adjustments needed to be made in the farming industry.

Farms needed to adapt to these new changes, they began this shift by creating more distance between people and changing the types of crops they must grow. Prioritizing to grow only essential crops, which are not as labor intensive, and to shift away from restaurant crops, like microgreens and edible flowers. Instead, they are adjusting to producing calorie dense crops that are more for retail accounts such as grocery stores.

In order to be able to produce enough crops in time due to people struggling to find affordable produce amid the coronavirus, the farm had to move up their planting schedule to be able to harvest sooner. The farm also limited contact during pickup of food boxes because before the outbreak, they allowed people to pick out their produce from open boxes, so instead they have the boxes closed and delivered them to low traffic areas such as building lobbies or residents’ floors.

This article demonstrates the change of how the perception of farmers and what they do was undermined because now midst the coronavirus outbreak, the interest of what farmers do and what they truly contribute has grown dramatically. COVID-19 has changed our world substantially, and is effecting the workplace and the system of places like Red Hook Farms. Farms like this are doing everything they can to still provide for others while suffering with having few employees and a higher work load. Detroit’s grocery stores do not have a lot of affordable organic food/produce. The people should not just rely on grocery stores and government resources, but support local farms as well.

Original article: https://thefern.org/ag_insider/virus-is-changing-how-urban-farms-operate-and-even-what-they-grow/

COVID-19 and the Problems Present in the Food Supply Chain

With the increasing spread of COVID-19 necessitating widespread shutdowns to locations such as restaurants, schools, and theme parks. These closures have left produce growers scrambling to find new areas of demand for their products as the food supply chain comes under substantial disruption. 

The problem within the food supply chain it seems is that there is a growing need in food banks that is not being addressed for numerous reasons. These reasons include grocery stores being unable to donate any produce due to their shelves becoming bare in the wake of panic shopping in the wake of COVID-19. In a Guardian article talking about the disruption in the global food supply chain, produce growers expressed concern financially take the huge losses that come from harvesting, packaging, and shipping to food banks when they are already facing losses from being unable to sell their produce, leading these farmers to ask for the US Department of Agriculture to step in and buy up the produce to donate to food banks to avoid hurting the finances of farms. 

However, in that same article food suppliers like Brent Erenwart, CEO of Houston Cold Storage, a food supplier have mentioned that food banks are full noting that “the supply chain is the grocery stores seem to be pretty heavy on product, farmers are throwing away stuff, and food banks are full. We don’t know where the demand lies”. 

These contradictory situations highlight how broken down the food distribution system is within the United States as food banks that desperately need the products are unable to find donations due to people purchasing large quantities of foodstuffs with only themselves in mind and economic realities making it tough for farmers to help alleviate the financial burden that comes from planting, packaging and shipping new produce. Finally, even if those problems can be solved, it fails to answer how food banks suffering from shortages can get produce sent to them consistently and reliably.  

These problems likely require some government intervention whether that be buying produce from the farmers to give to food banks which could help alleviate the financial burden of these farmers or helping direct food distribution that allows for produce to go into the hands of food banks that are suffering from food shortages, it remains to be seen if the government will take these steps. Still, it is vital that problems with the food distribution system must be addressed. 

Boxes of food are set up for a drive-through food distribution run by Food Bank for the Heartland on March 16 in Council Bluffs, Iowa. Photo Credit: Food Bank for the Heartland.

Farmworkers are essential!

Amidst this crisis, it is difficult to not feel useless at times, especially for someone who is used to being such a busy-body. Learning about and reflecting on the world food system sparks inspiration, yet makes me long for the days when I worked on the UW Farm. Like many, I am out of work due to the COVID-19 pandemic, and miss the long, yet rewarding days on the farm. Being so idle these days, I realize I sometimes took my wholesome farm life for granted, with access to local produce daily and constantly learning about the intricacies of organic food production. It seems that many people see being a farmer as a relatively easy job, in terms of the little education required. However, farming demands such fine attention to detail and an understanding of how farms operate cohesively as a system. 

Trying to feel connected to the outside world in some way, I came across an article on undocumented farmworkers while scrolling through news and politics. The article, by the New York Times, explained how immigrant farmworkers, most of which are undocumented, have been prescribed ‘essential work’ letters that prevent punishment for working during stay at home orders. While these letters don’t protect from deportation, measures have been shifted from ordinary undocumented workers to those who pose a threat to public safety.’ This allows these essential workers to feel more at ease, despite the high risk they are to contracting coronavirus. It is ironic to me that it took a public health crisis for the government to realize that immigrants are beneficial to our country, especially farmworkers. How can we continue to have the stigma of immigrants being ‘criminals’ and detrimental to the US, when in fact they are ensuring food safety for so many Americans? I resonate with these farmers, as I understand how crucial the agricultural sector is to the sustaining the well-being of a country. 

During this crisis, it is important to analyze systemic inequalities that are becoming more apparent, like the many hardships imposed on immigrant workers. It is these under-paid ‘essential workers’ that are holding up the upper class in America, and it is only now that society realizes how reliant the wealthy are to the poor. Deploying systems thinking and viewing the food system through a broader lens can help to reveal these inequities and understand how to restructure such weak points. Next time you take the convenience and selections at grocery stores for granted, reflect on the many hard workers that ensure food security across the country. 

 

-Reily Savenetti

Sources:

Jordan, Miriam. “Farmworkers, Mostly Undocumented, Become ‘Essential’ During Pandemic.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 2 Apr. 2020, www.nytimes.com/2020/04/02/us/coronavirus-undocumented-immigrant-farmworkers-agriculture.html.

Wasted Bounty: A Tale of Food All Grown Up and Nowhere To Go

Squash left to rot in the field. Florida City, Fla. | Joe Raedle/Getty Images via Politico

A wedge of purple cabbage is rediscovered at the bottom of the crisper drawer, wilted and slimy. I feel guilty for having forgotten its existence as I toss it into the compost bucket. What a luxurious problem to have – food going to waste. During an already stressful and scary time, the coronavirus pandemic is revealing both weaknesses and potential strengths in our food system, particularly in terms of food insecurity and waste. In a recent article published by the Food & Environment Reporting Network, author Elizabeth Royte discusses a shift in U.S. food waste patterns and rising food insecurity. More people are relying on food banks during this economic crisis, but grocery stores and food producers are selling what would have historically been surplus donated to food banks. School closures and reduced restaurant operations mean broken channels for farmers and falling prices for things like milk and asparagus, resulting in product dumping and produce left to rot in fields.

Is worrying about food waste trivial given everything else going on right now? Perhaps this is an opportunity to strengthen food networks and food justice. We can’t ignore so much wasted bounty at a time when the number of those in need is rising daily. It’s a time to demand higher working and living conditions for those who grow our food. Might we grow from these challenging times and advocate towards living wages and a future of food security? As market channels are disrupted and the future of food supplies are vulnerable, we must find ways of strengthening localized food networks to increase system resilience

There are on-the-ground and top-down efforts underway. Grassroots organizations across the country are working to connect surplus with need. The recent stimulus bill included aid for the USDA to purchase and deliver food to banks. This is not a drill. This is an opportunity for identifying system breakdowns and rebuilding a stronger, healthier food future.

 

 

 

 

Sources

Purdy, Chase. “Asparagus Prices Show How the Coronavirus Is Nipping at the Global Food System.” Quartz, Quartz, 11 Apr. 2020, qz.com/1836376/falling-asparagus-prices-show-coronavirus-impact-on-global-food-system/.

Royte, Elizabeth. “Food Waste–and Food Insecurity–Rising amid Coronavirus Panic.” Food and Environment Reporting Network, Food and Environment Reporting Network, 31 Mar. 2020, thefern.org/2020/03/food-waste-and-food-insecurity-rising-amid-coronavirus-panic/.

Yaffe-bellany, David, and Michael Corkery. “Dumped Milk, Smashed Eggs, Plowed Vegetables: Food Waste of the Pandemic.” The New York Times, The New York Times, 11 Apr. 2020, www.nytimes.com/2020/04/11/business/coronavirus-destroying-food.html.

Food Supply Chain Issues During Covid-19

While sifting through headlines a few mornings ago I stumbled across an article entitled, “Wisconsin farmers forced to dump milk as coronavirus slams a fragile dairy economy” from USA Today. Prior to this, I had been hearing about food shortages and had failed to consider that there may be food going to waste. When discussing the effects of coronavirus, a farmer in Wisconsin said, “Everybody’s rushing to the grocery store to get food, and we have food that’s literally being dumped down the drain.” This is an issue that is seen across the board in our food industry as it struggles to adapt to changing demands. 

Consumer behavior has shifted and left our food system scrambling to meet demand in grocery stores while food meant for restaurants is going to waste. This is creating food shortages and driving up costs for consumers. I see many people focusing on short term fixes as we wait for things to go back to normal. In my opinion, now that we have witnessed this issue, we have no choice but to find the means to solve it. It is unclear how long this pandemic will last and we now know that our food system is not as resilient as we would like to think.

For now, I see solutions in restaurants that are offering produce boxes and selling their food deliveries in order to keep up demand for farms. Long term, it is my opinion that we need to see the government step in and help manage our food supply. If we want our system to come out of this intact, we should be donating food to low-income people, finding ways to distribute food that would otherwise go to waste and make sure that food remains affordable and accessible for all.

The Hoarders, The Hungry, and the Problem with Individualism

Above: Shoppers Stockpile Supplies in response to Covid-19 Pandemic                                                 Below: People Wait in Line at a San Antonio Food Bank

With the recent lockdowns due to the Covid-19 pandemic and news stories dominated by pictures of empty grocery store shelves it is easy to feel like we will soon run out of food. Beans, medicine, and toilet paper are flying off the shelves and not just paranoid citizens are starting to stockpile, nations have also begun to hold on tighter to their resources.

Meanwhile, now more than ever the world’s hungry are in need. In the United States, food banks are being overwhelmed, and globally the World Food Programme estimates that 5.5 million people in central Sahel alone will be facing severe food insecurity in the coming months. The hoarders and the hungry; an epitome of a global food system that never seems to have enough to go around.

Yet, when you look closer into how that food is being used, there is an even more insidious note. Every year the United States wastes 40% of its food; 63 million tons a year. When 63 million tons of food a year is left to rot in one country alone, it is clear that the global food system doesn’t have a shortage issue, it has a distribution issue; a distribution issue exacerbated by rampant western individualism. People are, and have for a long time, purchased only with their own perceived needs in mind, without thinking about the larger scale implications that these actions have on others around the world. We live on a finite planet, with finite resources. Every meal you throw away is food that could have eased the hunger of someone else. It is time we wake up to the manufactured food crisis we have created, and in compassion, work toward a more equitable food distribution system, that decreases waste by calming the hoarders and feeding the hungry.

 

 

Changes in buyer’s behavior, not the lack of supply, could drive up prices

In a recent UN article, it was reported that so far the food supply and markets have been stable during the pandemic, and disruptions due to COVID-19 were minimal, but this could change for the worse very fast if anxiety-driven panic causes major food importers and bulk-buyers to begin ordering more products due to the fear of having a shortage.

This would lead to a disastrous situation where there would only be food available in areas these foods have been imported to, and not enough elsewhere, accelerating the issue of food insecurity globally during this pandemic. There is already a disproportionate impact on food security, as lower-income families are affected more, as more of their paychecks go into buying food. If panic-buying by major food importers ensue, this would drive up the prices of key foods such as wheat and grain products, and this would affect those that are already food insecure the most. The UN has reported that many developing countries, due to the fact that they are the most dependent on imports would be affected the most.

It is key that everyone has access to a healthy diet and food throughout the global fight against COVID-19, and one of the ways to mitigate that would be to no not panic-buy, starting at the importer level, but as individual consumers as well. We must all be mindful of each other and only buy what you need, so other people have the ability to have access to valuable resources as well. Maintaining a steady global food chain is a key focus during this pandemic, as a loss in this could prove to be catastrophic. We could all achieve this by not ensuing in panic buying or hoarding behavior!

Original Article: https://news.un.org/en/story/2020/04/1061032

Food Supply Chain Consequences of COVID-19

While the impacts of COVID-19 on the consumer food industry have already been felt via restaurant shutdowns and reduced grocery store hours, a recent article published by the International Food Policy Research Institute predicts that developing countries will soon also face food shortages and price inflation as a result of the virus.

According to the article, a majority of residents in Asia and Africa rely on small- and medium-scale food enterprises (SMEs) to satisfy their food needs. As the virus continues to necessitate the enactment of strict lockdowns, these enterprises will be unable to continue producing food due to their inability to meet new public health guidelines.

As supply dwindles, consumers can expect to pay more for less following a sharp increase in food prices.

As supply from SMEs (S-curve) shifts from S to S’, consumers (D-curve) will be forced to pay the resulting increased price (vertical axis) of p’. Many will not be able to afford this price. Image courtesy of Encyclopaedia Britannica: https://www.britannica.com./topic/supply-and-demand

Though the article does predict a short term increase in unemployment for these enterprises, it doesn’t recognize the long term consequences of shifting consumer preferences following a decrease in supply. Since consumers’ demand for food is stagnant, they will be forced to find other means of consumption if SMEs prove insolvent. The luckiest will be able to turn to large-scale enterprises, supply chains ending in supermarkets familiar to the Western consumer. Others will choose between starvation, poverty (if they accept inflated SME prices), and theft.

Unfortunately, no plausible solution comes without dire consequences, but failure to address the supply chain issue will leave entire countries in turmoil.

Governments of developing countries must either subsidize SMEs by providing materials necessary to produce food safely or ask for support from large-scale enterprises to avoid eventual famine. While the latter will further cement the monopoly these enterprises hold on the world food system, the severity of the consequences following adherence to the status-quo demands immediate action, and these large firms may be the best equipped to provide it.

Food Supply Chain “Strong” But Questions Remain

Washington State Governor Jay Inslee declared a statewide shutdown of restaurants and other public spaces back on March 15th, assuring Washingtonians that the supply chain was strong, hoping to alleviate fears and hoarding by consumers. And while grocery stores have remained open, albeit with sparsely stocked hand soap and toilet paper shelves, an NPR article released a few days later raised questions about the trying times about to strike those in a different—yet equally vital—part of the supply chain: agricultural workers.

Workers in Wapato, WA. Photo Credit: Elaine Thompson/AP

The good news is that most seasonal workers coming from Mexico will still qualify for their H-2A visas. The bad news is that these people will be traveling far and wide, often living in close proximity to one another once they reach their employer’s fields, meaning exposure to COVID-19 is a strong possibility. While distributors and farmers deal with the logistical and financial strain of re-routing products from shuttered restaurants, the last thing they need is a labor shortage.

So what can be done? Greater government involvement in clean and safe housing for workers? Incentives for workers exposing themselves in travelling long distances across borders and state lines, like short-term medical benefits, or insurance, for seasonal workers, to protect them if they fall ill? And what of farms that will be closing from decline in business?

A chain is only as strong as its weakest link. COVID-19 has put our healthcare system in crisis. No matter your politics, it is clear our systems simply aren’t geared for dealing with a calamity. In the age of the Anthropocene it hardly seems this current health crisis will be the end of hard-times. If we don’t prepare now, addressing weaknesses in our systems, the next crisis we face could mean not just soap and paper products disappear from store shelves.